In short
The four models solve different problems. A permanent hire suits steady long-term demand, consulting suits analysis and concepts, and interim management bridges a leadership role. Procurement as a Service takes on defined procurement tasks and delivers results, on an ongoing basis or per project.
The models compared
| Procurement as a Service | Consulting | Interim management | Permanent hire | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you buy | Completed procurement tasks | Analysis, concept, recommendation | A role filled for a limited period | Long-term capacity |
| Typical use | Tenders, negotiations, supplier checks, ongoing purchasing | Strategy, organisation, processes | Vacant leadership role, restructuring | Steady demand |
| Implementation | Yes, by the provider | Usually by the company | Yes, by the individual | Yes |
| Adjusting the scope | By agreement | Per project | Per assignment | Only through headcount planning |
| Dependence on one person | Low, team and cover | Medium | High | High |
| Start | After the proposal and access are agreed | After the proposal | After selecting the individual | After the post is filled |
Comparing cost properly
Compare total cost, not day or hourly rates against gross salaries. A permanent post also brings employer contributions, equipment, software, training, holidays and sick leave. In 2025 an hour of work cost an average of €45.00 in Germany (Destatis) and €56.80 in Luxembourg (Eurostat). Allow for the time it takes to fill a post as well: 160 days on average in 2024 for registered vacancies in Germany (Federal Employment Agency).
Legal points when engaging individuals
If you engage individuals on a freelance basis in Germany, clarify their employment status. The clearing office of the German pension insurance fund (Deutsche Rentenversicherung Bund) issues a binding decision on whether the work counts as self-employment or employment (Deutsche Rentenversicherung). The decision rests on an overall assessment of the individual case (Section 7a SGB IV). Have this checked before work begins, whichever model you choose.
Combinations that make sense
- Permanent team plus PaaS: the team covers the core, external capacity handles peaks and specialist topics
- Consulting plus PaaS: concept and implementation from one source or awarded separately
- Interim plus PaaS: bridge the leadership role and secure operational work externally
Author
Dennis Rossbach
Dennis Rossbach is the founder and managing director of SYBX Group Sàrl in Luxembourg and has worked in procurement for 15 years, including for defence, energy, public sector bodies and manufacturing.
Sources
- Destatis (Federal Statistical Office of Germany): labour costs 2025
- Eurostat: hourly labour costs in the EU 2025
- Bundesagentur für Arbeit (Federal Employment Agency): vacancy duration
- Deutsche Rentenversicherung: status determination procedure
- Section 7a SGB IV (German Social Code, Book IV)
- Further reading: SYBX Group: the true cost of procurement capacity
Would you like to discuss your situation?
In a free initial conversation we clarify the task, the objective and the constraints, by phone, by video or in person.
Request an initial conversation