In short
Suppliers and dual-use companies entering the defence market have to prove more than price and quality: a resilient supply chain, security of supply over the service life, protection of classified information, export control and often NATO quality requirements. Much of this evidence is produced in procurement, because it concerns the sub-tier suppliers.
What contracting authorities can ask for
The EU directive on defence and security procurement allows contracting authorities to ask explicitly about two areas (Directive 2009/81/EC):
- Security of information (Article 22): confidentiality commitments from the tenderer and any subcontractors already identified, an obligation to obtain the same commitments from further subcontractors, and information on subcontractors so that their ability to protect classified information can be assessed
- Security of supply (Article 23): evidence that the organisation and location of the supply chain meet the requirements, and commitments to meet additional needs in a crisis and to carry out maintenance, modernisation and adaptation
Checklist for procurement
| Area | What to prepare | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Supply chain | Overview of sub-tier suppliers with origin, single sources and second sources | Directive 2009/81/EC, Article 23 |
| Supplier commitments | Capacity, ability to deliver in a crisis, spare parts and documentation over the service life | Directive 2009/81/EC, Article 23 |
| Confidentiality | Non-disclosure agreements with sub-tier suppliers that can be flowed down | Directive 2009/81/EC, Article 22 |
| Quality | Quality management based on ISO 9001:2015, AQAP-2110 where the contract requires it, requirements flowed down to suppliers | AQAP-2110 |
| Export control | Check goods, software and technology against the EU dual-use list, clarify licences for inputs | Regulation (EU) 2021/821 |
NATO quality requirements
AQAP-2110 sets out NATO quality assurance requirements for design, development and production. Suppliers must operate a quality management system that incorporates ISO 9001:2015 (Bundeswehr, AQAP-2110-SRD.3). For procurement, this means requirements on traceability and quality have to be written into contracts with sub-tier suppliers.
Export control
In the EU, goods, software and technology that can be used for both civilian and military purposes fall under the Dual-Use Regulation (EU) 2021/821. Most of these items can be traded freely within the EU, but particularly sensitive items need an authorisation even there (European Commission). Establish early which inputs are affected and who is responsible for licences.
Classified information in Germany and Luxembourg
- Germany: for classified information at the lowest level (VS-NUR FÜR DEN DIENSTGEBRAUCH), control rights lie with the public contracting authority. A classified contract in the narrower sense only exists from VS-VERTRAULICH upwards (VS-NfD guidance). The Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy supervises companies' protection of classified information, including security vetting of staff (BMWE)
- Luxembourg: security clearances are issued by the National Security Authority (Autorité nationale de sécurité, ANS), including to companies that can show adequate material and technical means to protect classified information (State Intelligence Service)
Security vetting and certification take time. Start before a specific tender is published.
Common mistakes when entering the market
- Discovering the requirements only when preparing the bid
- Not involving sub-tier suppliers, so commitments are missing
- Checking export control for the end product only, not for inputs and technology
How Procurement as a Service helps
An external partner can take on supply chain and dependency analysis, the qualification of sub-tier suppliers and flowing requirements down into contracts. Decisions, approvals and responsibility for licences stay with the company.
Author
Dennis Rossbach
Dennis Rossbach is the founder and managing director of SYBX Group Sàrl in Luxembourg and has worked in procurement for 15 years, including for defence, energy, public sector bodies and manufacturing.
Sources
- Directive 2009/81/EC on defence and security procurement, Articles 22 and 23
- Bundeswehr: AQAP-2110-SRD.3 (NATO quality assurance requirements)
- European Commission: exporting dual-use items (Regulation (EU) 2021/821)
- Bundeswehr: VS-NfD guidance on handling classified information
- German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy: security in business
- Luxembourg State Intelligence Service: security clearances
- Further reading: SYBX Group: Dual-Use Procurement Readiness
Would you like to discuss your situation?
In a free initial conversation we clarify the task, the objective and the constraints, by phone, by video or in person.
Request an initial conversation